Can Leaders Be Friends?

Can leaders be friends with the people they lead? 

For years I thought the answer was no. Today, I believe great leadership isn't built on distance—it's built on trust. 

Join me as we discuss how to build lasting relationships, hold people accountable with grace, and leave a leadership legacy that outlasts your title.

Transcript

Copy Transcript Copied

Speaker 0:00

Welcome to the Biblical Leadership at Work podcast. I'm your host, Jason Woodard. For years, I believed something that almost every leader I worked for believed. They said, "Don't become friends with the people who work for you." Now, the reasoning always sounded logical. If you're too close, you won't be objective. If you're too friendly, you won't hold people accountable. If you build personal relationships, you won't be able to fire someone if it becomes necessary. So many of us learn to keep our teams at an arm's length, be professional, be approachable, but don't get too close, and for many years, I accepted that as unquestioned leadership wisdom. But today, I don't believe it anymore. Proverbs twenty-seven, six says, "Faithful are the wounds of a friend." And then Jesus says something remarkable to his disciples in John fifteen. He says, "No longer do I call you servants. I have called you friends," Now, think about that. Jesus called them friends, yet he also corrected them. He rebuked Peter. He challenged Thomas. He confronted their pride. He held them accountable consistently. But friendship never weakened his leadership. If anything, it strengthened it. I think somewhere along the way, we've confused two different ideas, being emotionally close and having poor boundaries. Those aren't the same thing. Poor leaders blur boundaries, but strong leaders build trust, and that's a world of difference. Over the years, I started noticing something. The people I had the greatest developmental impact on were usually the people that I knew best, the ones that I had spent time with, the ones whose families I knew, the ones who trusted me most. Those were the people who accepted difficult feedback, not because criticism was easier, but because they trusted my motives. When I challenged them, they never questioned whether I was for them. They already knew. So trust changed everything. I have learned something that leadership books don't always tell us. Distance doesn't create influence. Trust does. If someone believes you genuinely care about them, they'll often accept coaching that someone else could never give. They know you're trying to help them become better, not protect your position, not win an argument, not prove that you're smarter. You just want to help them grow, and that changes the entire conversation Some leaders think accountability requires emotional distance. I think accountability requires credibility. Think about it in your own life. Who's allowed to challenge you? Usually, it's the people you trust the most, the people who've earned the right, not because they're loud, not because they have authority, but because they've demonstrated they care. That's what gives hard conversations their power. Now, does this mean that we ignore reality? No. I've always been more cautious with employees who consistently struggle, not because I care less about them, but because I recognize there may come a day when difficult employment decisions have to be made, and I don't want kindness to be mistaken for promises that I can't keep. But here's something else I've learned. I've had to terminate people that I genuinely cared about. I've had to terminate fellow Christians. The employment relationship ended, but our relationship in Christ did not. They were still my brother. They were still my sister. Sometimes leadership requires difficult decisions. It should never require us to stop caring about people. One of the ways I've come to understand this is by thinking about parenting. I love my children deeply, and I hold them accountable. Those aren't competing ideas. In fact, because they know I love them, they're much more likely to hear corrections from me. Now, leadership isn't parenting. The relationships are different, but the principle is similar. Accountability works best inside relationships that are built on trust. Now, let me be clear. Relationships don't eliminate boundaries. Leaders should never play favorites, never compromise confidentiality, never avoid conversations because someone is close to them, never lower standards because they like someone personally. Those are not friendship problems. Those are leadership problems. You can genuinely care about people and still be completely fair The older I get, the more I realize that leadership isn't measured by how many people report to you. It's measured by the impact you have had on the people you are leading. I'm honored to still have people who worked for me ten and fifteen years ago reach out and stay connected, and sometimes seek advice or help. They don't call because I'm their boss anymore. I'm not. They call because somewhere along the line, we built trust. And that, to me, is one of the greatest compliments a leader can receive. It tells me the relationship wasn't transactional, it was transformational. If someone only wants to hear from you while you sign their paycheck, you may have been their manager. But if they still seek your wisdom years after you've worked together, you've become something much more valuable. You've become one of the people who helped shape their life, and that is real leadership So here's my challenge for you this month. Don't ask yourself, "Am I keeping enough professional distance?" Instead, ask, "Am I building enough trust that people know I genuinely care about them?" Invest in someone. Take them to lunch. Ask about their family. Pray for them if that's appropriate. Learn what they're hoping to accomplish in life. Then, when it's time to coach them, tell them the truth. Not because you're frustrated, not because you need to prove a point. Tell them the truth because you care too much not to. someday they will not work for you anymore. I hope many of them move on to bigger opportunities. The question is, will they still call you five years from now, ten years from now? Will they still seek your advice? Will they still trust your counsel? Because if they do, you didn't just manage their performance, you influenced their life, and I can't think of a better definition of leadership than that. So until next time, lead boldly, love your people, tell them the truth, and remember, the best leaders don't build careers that people remember. They build relationships that people never forget.